Cape May’s Top-Rated Eateries: A Foodie’s Guide

Cape May is a lovely city and seaside resort in the County, located at the tip of New Jersey’s Peninsula. The city’s shoreline is surrounded by stunning Victorian-style mansions. You can get mesmerizing views of Delaware Bay and the Atlantic Ocean from there. This city in the US is famous for two things; its magnificent architecture and its top-notch seafood and restaurants that serve a wide range of cuisines.

Let’s walk through the 10 Best Restaurants in Cape May, NJ.

Top 10 Popular Eateries in Cape May, NJ

If you want to enjoy Greek cuisine while admiring the stunning coastline, George’s Place is the place to be. Due to its ideal location on Beach Avenue, cozy ambiance, and mouthwatering meals, it is a popular dining spot in Cape May among locals and visitors.

It serves traditional American cuisine as well as traditional Greek and Mediterranean fare. Start your day right with breakfast quesadillas, smoked salmon scrambles, hash browns, or omelets served with toast. You can eat according to your mood.

At this restaurant, the chipped beef is cooked every day, the waffles are crisp on the surface and light on the inside, the sandwich wraps are packed like Santa’s bag on Christmas Eve, and the Greek family who manage it are welcoming and on top of their game.

What you should not miss over there is the cheeseburger with fries, hummus, tzatziki, or a Greek street wrap for lunch, or a falafel pita with fries. The dishes switch when the sun is low in the sky. Evening menu items at this restaurant include salmon, crab cakes, chicken Santorini, chicken souvlaki, shrimp saganaki, and shrimp saganaki. So, what are you waiting for? Add it to your list for an amazing experience.

The next one is 410 Bank Street. When you walk into this lushly landscaped restaurant, you will experience a natural vibe. The furnishings of the house take you back in time. Antique highlights, wrought-iron furniture, and arched windows makes you feel as if you have entered the Victorian era.

When it comes to cuisine, 410 Bank Street serves New Orleans-style French-influenced Caribbean cuisine. Tourists can enjoy dishes such as Jamaican steak, grilled Norwegian salmon, Cape May mahi-mahi, and blackened prime rib at this restaurant.

For customers with special dietary needs, the restaurant offers gluten-free versions of dishes such as Havana Bay shrimp, catfish creole, roast pig, and others. We recommend trying one of their freshly made sweets to finish your meal on a sweet note. It’s delectable. You will never regret trying 410 Bank Street because the vibe is totally different. So, don’t forget to add this one to your list.

The third on our list is The Ebbitt Room, located on Jackson Street. It serves new American cuisine next to the picture-perfect Victorian homes. The leather chairs, hardwood interiors, and brilliant chandeliers at the restaurant reflect Cape May’s Victorian charm.

The farm-to-table restaurant has a classy yet relaxed atmosphere. It is perfect for tourists looking for a special Cape May dining occasion. Rainbow trout, Cape May scallops, braised lamb shank, 12 oz. prime NY strip, and Atlantic swordfish are some of the items from the main course of this eatery.

Talking about the desert, Ebbitt includes handcrafted ice cream, key lime pie, banoffee pie, and a flourless chocolate torte made with farm-fresh eggs from Beach Plum Farm. Handcrafted drinks, such as sangria, daiquiris, margaritas, martinis, and other sparkling cocktails and non-alcoholic beverages, go well with the meals. With such delicious meals, The Ebbitt Room deserves at least one visit. If it’s near and you are hungry, never miss out.

Tourists who are craving greenery should reach this restaurant. The Beach Plum Farm provides a change of scenery. It’s not like the beachfront restaurants, bars, and shops. The farm and restaurant are surrounded by 62 acres of lush vegetation. It raises Berkshire hogs, chickens, and eggs, as well as hundreds of different fruits and vegetables.

In addition, the farm supplies food to several nearby restaurants, including Louisa’s Cafe, the Blue Pig Tavern, and The Ebbitt Room. You can learn about how Beach Plum Farm grows and produces a variety of fruits and vegetables using sustainable and regenerative farming techniques.

Afterward, you can dine at The Farm Kitchen for breakfast, lunch, or dinner in a delightful rural setting. Enjoy the freshly collected fruit and vegetables. When you visit, you can be certain that you will have a unique, wholesome, and delectable dinner. It is because the menu changes based on the available ingredients. But every meal has its own taste and we are 100% your taste buds are going to love it. So, open your book and pen it down.

Sapore Italiano brings a taste of Italy to the streets of Cape May. With its authentic Italian cuisine, the restaurant lies in the fifth spot in our list of top 10 popular eateries in Cape May. This South Broadway restaurant makes its own pasta from scratch and uses ingredients sourced locally. Moreover, It is housed in a Victorian-era structure.

We recommend you to start with the eggplant rollatini or beet and goat cheese salad as an appetizer before moving on to other dishes like risotto, gnocchi pomodoro, or pollo alla parmigiano. Seafood-based pasta dishes such as risotto alla pescatore, linguine alla vongole, and spaghetti alla sapore are also available at the restaurant. You can ask about the catch of the day with your waitress.

To accompany your meal, you are welcome to bring your own bottle of wine or to purchase a bottle of red or white wine from a nearby winery. The restaurant allows that. In the end, the dessert includes Sicilian cannoli, New York-style cheesecake, or tiramisu ladyfinger. We are sure your Italian craving will never go unsatisfied after eating at this restaurant. So, give it a try.

If you have plans to visit California next, do check out 12 Italian Restaurants You Should Visit in Laguna Beach to satisfy the cravings.

This restaurant offers you the rarest opportunity to dine in a structure and environment that dates back to 1846. It is one of Cape May’s must-try restaurants. The restaurant has undergone several renovations, but it has retained its stately beauty and architectural style, which is reminiscent of George Washington’s former plantation home, Mount Vernon. People flock to this restaurant for the love of history and food.

Talking about the meals, Yellowfin tuna poke, crab and corn chowder, curry cauliflower steak, grilled swordfish, and their signature crab cakes are available at the eatery. Traditions may cause changes to the menu. Don’t forget to finish your meal with a chocolate mousse cake or a coconut napoleon, or a glass of red, white, or dessert wine.

Washington Inn is also known for its cocktails, which include the Oaxacan inferno, rum punch, and mezcal negroni. Do try them as well on your trip to Cape May, New Jersey.

If you are into seafood and looking for a calm and satisfying place to eat, reach Cape May Fish Market. They provide the best seafood meals in the area. Because of its convenient location along Washington Street, the seafood restaurant is a popular dining destination for tourists and shoppers.

The restaurant offers a wide range of selections of salads, burgers, sandwiches, pasta, and other dishes to cater to different taste buds. They also serve chicken and steak for those who prefer meat to seafood. If you have plans to visit the Middle East, we can help you in Finding the Best Seafood Restaurants in Dubai as well.

Their specialties include fish or crab cake soft taco wraps, fish & chips, crab cake grilled cheese, crab cake croissants, and the Philadelphia plate. Hence, there are numerous options to satisfy your cravings when you are at Cape May Fish Market. It is highly recommended to try their seafood on your trip.

The Union Park Eating Room at the historic Hotel Macombe provides an ideal blend of upscale and casual dining. The restaurant is located just a few steps from the beach. Moreover, it has been listed among the Best Restaurants in Cape May, NJ.

Three courses make up its menu. You can get light salads, crab cakes, or fresh oysters for the first course, and chicken, lobster, salmon, steak, and pork are available for the second course.

Union Park Dining Room offers a chocolate pastry, fruit tart, basque-burned cheesecake, or ice cream as a third course to round out your fine dining experience. To complement your meal, you can select a white, red, or rosé wine from their hand-crafted premium New Jersey wines list. It will make a perfect ride for the taste buds with a sweet end. Don’t miss out!

The Blue Pig Tavern, with its distinctive red chairs and cozy atmosphere, is one of Cape May’s must-try restaurants. Therefore, we have included this one in our list. It is housed in Congress Hall, which is one of the country’s oldest beach resorts. It has been open since 1816.

The restaurant, named after a former casino, serves traditional and seasonal American cuisine made with farm-fresh ingredients. Blue Pig Tavern got you covered from breakfast to dinner. Whether you want fresh omelets in the morning or a pulled pork sandwich for lunch, the eatery is at your service.

You can also order seafood over there as the menu includes traditional shrimp cocktails, chilled seafood platters, shucked oysters, and steamed mussels. Thus, options are not ending. So, add it to your list.

Tisha’s Fine Dining is a charming restaurant located along busy Washington Street. It is best for people who don’t mind others watching them, while they eat. The restaurant has indoor, outdoor, and al fresco dining options.

The restaurant first opened its doors in 1988 in Wildwood, New Jersey. It was later relocated to Cape May and changed its name to Tisha’s Fine Dining. Despite the name change, it continues to provide the same level of service and food quality to customers.

The specialties of this eatery include a pork Milanese sandwich, crab cake tacos, chicken BLT, salmon po’boy, and a blackened chicken sandwich that you should not miss. Because Tisha’s Fine Dining is a BYO establishment, we recommend you take your own wine bottle to accompany the meal on your trip.

If you liked our collection, we recommend you to check out 8 Fine Dining Restaurants In Germantown as well. We are super sure you will love that write-up as well.

Things to Consider

Cape May offers a variety of activities and attractions for visitors to enjoy. Hopdes recommends some things to consider when planning a trip to Cape May including:

• Nature — Cape May is surrounded by protected wildlife reserves, and visitors can enjoy walking and hiking trails, bird watching, and also wildlife viewing. The Cape May bird observatory, located at the Point State Park, is a popular spot for birdwatching and offers guided walks and birding programs.
• Accommodation — Visitors can choose from a variety of accommodation options, including hotels, bed and breakfasts, and vacation rentals. There are a number of hotels and resorts in the area, ranging from budget-friendly options to luxury resorts. Many of these offer amenities such as swimming pools, fitness centers, and on-site restaurants.
• Transportation — Some important things to consider are whether you will bring your own car or you plan to use public transportation, bike, or walk to get around. Having a car is the most convenient way to get around Cape May and the surrounding area, as it allows for easy access to all the attractions and activities in the area. There is a country-wide bus service as well. The Wave Transit offers service to all major towns in the county. The service runs Monday through Saturday, with limited service on Sundays.
• Weather — Cape May has a humid subtropical climate, with warm summers and mild winters. Be sure to check the forecast and pack accordingly. During spring (March to May) temperatures average around 50-60°F (10-15°C) during the day, and 40-50°F (5-10°C) at night. When summer comes (June to August), the temperatures average around 70-80°F (20-27°C) during the day and 60-70°F (15-21°C) at night, with occasional heat waves. This is the peak season for tourism, and the weather is usually ideal for swimming, sunbathing, and outdoor activities.

How Do We Pick Recommendations

Our team members love to travel and never pass up the chance to visit other countries and experience other cultures. We visit different states of America frequently. One of our team members visits Cape May every year to learn about what has changed. Hopdes treats visitors as members of the family, so we chose these Best Restaurants in Cape May, NJ to make your vacations memorable.